Frank Zehentner 1955
J. Edwin LeFever February 19, 1944
George Reed September 24, 1948
Robert Shea October 9, 1949?
William Simpson 1949
John Selentano August 5, 1951
William Hannaweber
Pierre J. Muller 1951
Harold E. O’Brien April 26, 1952
Frank Amatrano January 27, 1953
Henry L. Dittmar 1953
Henry Hummel 1953
John Daly 1953
Rev. David Weidner May 5, 1955
Arthur Fleischer October 22, 1955?
Edward Bernard April 20, 1956
George Lutzenberger 1956
Kenneth Brady August 11, 1956?
Robert Taylor April 26, 1958
Willet V. Roosa April 24, 1958
Harvey Deitz September 26, 1958
Joseph Yunker (Charter Member) (Past Chief) April 4, 1959
Nicholas Ricco July 1959?
Cornelius “Neal” R. Hotaling July 16, 1959
Edward Brodsky
Edmond V. Dession (Charter Member) 1961
Floyd Evory April 26, 1961
James Coutant (Charter Member) February 15, 1962?
Karl Pederson
Adolph Sterbenz (Charter Member)
Pvt. John “Charlie” Markle (Charter Member) October 4, 1962
Joseph Assion
John Welch 1963
Joseph Zehentner April 7, 1963
Joseph Muller
Thomas Bly
Murius Don
Cuyler Van Vechten February 10, 1965
Carl Gustafson March 14, 1965
William Burns 1965
Aaron Relyea 1965
John Amatrano
Edmond Riccobono November 12, 1965
Cornelius LeFevre 1965
Jason Egan
Harry Wheeler January 30, 1966
Charles Reilly May 9, 1966
Frank Whitman
Charles Doty
Floyd Williams July 1, 1967
Gerhard Schneider July 20, 1967
George Kohloff August 1, 1967
Konrad Hoppe 1967
Phillip Sutton
William Wershing
Albert Hartman
Otto Lockle
Earl Mack Sr.
John Plonski September 19, 1971
Dr. Leander Rymph January 1, 1973
William(Willy) Von Ohlen July 13, 1973
Raymond Keator 1973
John Jagschitz December 1, 1974?
Joseph Knubben
George Sagar Sr.
Henry Osterhaudt 1976
John Bordenstein Sr. 1980?
Leo Yonnetti (Charter Member) May 7, 1976
Frank Yonnetti 1976
Frederick Warncke September 19, 1976
Frank McElrath (Charter Member)
Robert Racicot (Charter Member) February 23, 1978
Theodore Riccobono July 1980?
Kenneth Bordenstein June 1, 1980
John Bordenstein June 17, 1980
Frederick Hofbauer April 6, 1982
Henry Muller
John Lukasz 1983
Frederick Sauer (First President)
William Markle June 1984?
Charles F. Peterson (Past President) May 25, 1984
John Maschino 1986?
Walter Fatum June 11, 1985
Jerome Mack
Oscar Hahn (Past Chief) October 22, 1987
Earl Gilchrist April 5, 1988
Rudolph Beyersdorfer October 3, 1988
Richard Priepke July 30, 1989
Howard Slover 1991
Roland Drolett June 17, 1993
Matteo Zanni July 15, 1993
Amedeo Contini January 18, 1994
John Lane Sr. August 31, 1994
Henry Yonnetti (Charter Member) August 11, 1995
Joseph O’Connor (Charter Member)
Martin Lynch
George Moylan Sr. December 27, 1995
Arthur G. Fugazzi January 19, 1996
Eugene Yonnetti May 7, 1998
Vincent Finnerty (Past Chief) December 4, 1998
Robert L. Taylor April 3, 1999
Raymond Jackson April 26, 1999
James Johnson
John “Jack” Perrett July 4, 2000
Robert Tolfsen (President in Term) November 21, 2001
Charles McLain November 20, 2003
Roy Taylor (Charter Member) December 18, 2003
Jack Moseley December 18, 2004
George E. Hafner January 28, 2005
Todd Smith February 6, 2005 (LODD New Paltz FD)
Thomas Yonnetti March 4, 2006
Leslie Evory August 18, 2007
Kenneth Woolsey November 8, 2007
Rev. Wilhelm Haysom (First Chief) November 13, 2007
Joseph Sagar November 29, 2007
John “Jack” Tyler (Past President) March 15, 2008
Warren Prandoni (Past President and Chief) May 25, 2009
Phillip Hawver Sr. November 11, 2009
Peter Costa November 29, 2009
Herbert F. Faurote (Chief in Term) June 23, 2010
Daniel Stegner March 4, 2012
Edward Drucker October 11, 2012
Fred Harries Jr. November 7, 2012
Raymond LeFever December 16, 2012
Walter F. Swarthout Sr. (Charter Member) February 10, 2013
Robert Spindler February 15, 2013
Frank Moseley April 26, 2013
Kevin Bouyea October 4, 2013
James D. Craig (Past Chief – Binnewater FD) October 29, 2013
Timothy Rowell January 19, 2014
George J. Moylan Jr. February 15, 2014
Robert Hicks December 27, 2014
Clarence V. Coogan (Past Chief – Binnewater FD) February 29, 2016
Vernon A. Ronk (Past Chief – Binnewater FD) May 27, 2016
Alan J. Tyler (Past President) June 8, 2016
Michael J. Doria (Past President – Binnewater) July 14, 2016
William T. Hotaling (Binnewater FD) November 5, 2016
Egbert Mack June 7, 2017
Michael Drucker October 30, 2017
Thomas T. Barringer September 28, 2019
Andrew J. Lord Jr. September 4, 2020
Thomas E. McElrath Sr. January 6, 2021
Brian Hathaway February 13, 2021
Charles A. Phillips May 26, 2021
Michael Hines June 15, 2021
Peter A. Lavezzo Jr. September 25, 2021
Joseph Lucido October 27, 2022
Richard “Dick” Keller 12/21/2022
Richard Glazer (Honorary Member) November 17, 2023
Louis Klein (Honorary Member) January 25, 2024
Anton J. “Tony” Stegner July 14, 2024
Albert “Al” Schmidt June 9, 2025
John Quick July 17, 2025